A federal judge in Los Angeles has dismissed a number of claims in an American International Group lawsuit against Bank of America over mortgage securities issued by Countrywide Financial, although AIG has promised to continue its legal efforts to recoup more than $10 billion in MBS losses. U.S. District Judge Mariana Pfaelzer of the Central District of California in a new ruling dismissed AIG’s federal securities-law claims because they were filed too late – more than three years after the MBS were first sold. AIG filed suit against BofA as Countrywide’s owner and Merrill Lynch in New York state court...

The settlement baked into the Residential Capital bankruptcy agreement is facing new challenges, including one from Warren Buffet’s Berkshire Hathaway and another from unsecured creditors. When ResCap announced its bankruptcy last month, it did so with a plan to sell its mortgage origination platform and servicing rights to Nationstar Mortgage, a division of Fortress Investment Group, for $4 billion and its portfolio loans to its parent company Ally Financial. Part of the deal is a release of legal liability for Ally, which will pass along some of its lingering obligations – like follow through on the...

In an effort to standardize its commercial mortgage-backed security rating criteria, Standard & Poor’s plans to establish a single, all-around framework for rating U.S. and Canadian CMBS transactions. The credit rating agency is seeking comment on proposed criteria for structuring a new CMBS rating framework, which would be used to evaluate stand-alone, large loan and conduit/fusion CMBS transactions. Based on a representative sample of CMBS deals, a modest, limited impact on ratings may be expected on 25 percent of rated CMBS tranches, S&P said. The proposed criteria generally assume a...

More than 1,800 comment letters were apparently not enough. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau reopened the comment period last week on the pending ability-to-repay rule, with an emphasis on data relating to debt-to-income ratios. The rule will define “qualified mortgages” and the Dodd-Frank Act mandates that it be finalized by January 21, 2013. Data on agency mortgages helped prompt the request for comments, and the CFPB said it is hoping for similar data on mortgages in non-agency mortgage-backed securities ...

Non-agency mortgage-backed security investors and politicians on both sides of the aisle were critical this week of the recent $25.0 billion servicing settlement. The settlement requires principal reduction loan modifications on mortgages held in five banks’ portfolios and allows the servicers to receive credit for reducing principal on mortgages in non-agency MBS. Vincent Fiorillo, a trading/portfolio manager at Doubleline Capital, noted that the Association of Mortgage Investors is not opposed to principal reduction mods ...

Walter Investment Management is scheduled next week to begin subservicing the first batch of up to 30,000 mortgages in non-agency mortgage-backed securities for Bank of America. The transfer will mark the latest shift from BofA to subservicers as part of a still-disputed $8.5 billion proposed settlement with non-agency MBS investors. Nine subservicers were approved as part of the settlement: Acqura Loan Services, Bayview Loan Servicing, FCI Lender Services, Nationstar Mortgage, Residential Credit Solutions ...

Moody’s Investors Service announced last week that it is reviewing $47.5 billion in outstanding non-agency mortgage-backed securities for possible rating action. In a change of pace, however, most of the securities are being reviewed for potential upgrades. A whopping 78.3 percent of the combined subprime, Alt A, option ARM and jumbo MBS in question could potentially be upgraded. “The upgrade reviews are due to significant improvement in collateral performance and/or faster-than-expected pay-down on ...

If investors in non-agency mortgage-backed securities had easy access to the addresses of mortgages included in non-agency MBS, the sector’s market share would increase, according to a new proposal by the Reason Foundation, which promotes libertarian principles. “Ignorance of the borrower’s address and identity is a major disadvantage for the residential MBS investor or anyone trying to analyze residential MBS deals,” according to Marc Joffe, a research associate at the Reason Foundation and Anthony Randazzo ...

Making the Department of Veterans Affairs’ adjustable-rate mortgage programs permanent would cost $144 million in new direct taxpayer subsidies over the next 10 years, according to Congressional Budget Office estimates. Based on the number of ARM and hybrid ARM loans the VA has guaranteed in recent years, CBO estimates that the VA would guarantee approximately $1.3 billion worth of additional loans annually over the next 10 years. Consequently, additional subsidy costs for those loans would increase direct spending by $52 million over 2012-2017 and $144 million over 2012-2022, the CBO said. Subsidy costs of those additional loan guarantees would be paid from a ...

A proposal to replace the FHA’s current Tier Ranking System with a Servicer Performance Scorecard as a basis for determining servicer incentive payment is expected to be published in the Federal Register by the end of this month. In the previous issue of Inside FHA Lending (Volume 5, Issue 11, May 25), it was reported that a coalition of industry groups asked the FHA to adopt a private transfer fee rule in harmony with the final rule recently adopted by the Federal Housing Finance Agency. In a recent seller/servicer bulletin, Freddie Mac announced that, effective July 16, it will not purchase mortgages that are ...