The mortgage securitization and servicing industries say proposed changes to the servicing compensation model for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac securities would have a negative effect on liquidity in the to-be-announced market, hurt investors in agency MBS and increase the cost of mortgage credit for borrowers. The Federal Housing Finance Agency released a discussion paper last fall that outlined two potential new approaches to servicing compensation: a fee-for-service approach favored by the two government-sponsored enterprises, and a reserve account approach developed by lender...

In 2011, high-touch subprime servicer Carrington Mortgage Services significantly decreased its delinquency processing timelines and had its servicer rating confirmed at the end of the year. The servicer also made adjustments after facing criticism from non-agency mortgage-backed security investors who claimed that Carrington’s practices improperly favored investments made by the hedge fund that also owns the servicer. Carrington serviced $11.73 billion in subprime mortgages as of the end of the third quarter of 2011, according to estimates by Inside Nonconforming Markets. The servicer received a mid-range rating for subprime and special servicing from Fitch Ratings, with the rating service recently confirming that Carrington “demonstrates proficiency in overall servicing ability.” ...

Loan modifications with principal reduction have significantly increased in the past year, with servicers seeing improved performance compared with other types of mods. The mods remain concentrated on securitized non-agency mortgages as well as portfolio loans, but performance varies considerably. After falling to a 2.7 percent share in the fourth quarter of 2010, principal reduction mods have accounted for a growing share of bank and thrift mod activity, according to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Principal reduction was used in 7.8 percent of the mods completed by nine major bank and thrift servicers in the third quarter of 2011. ...

The Department of Housing and Urban Development has entered into a partnership agreement with the National Community Stabilization Trust to facilitate the implementation of a “first look” program that will give preference to certain purchasers to acquire FHA real estate-owned properties. In a notice published in the Federal Register, HUD announced the issuance of a universal Name and Address Identification Number (NAID) to the NCST to assist eligible buyers in purchasing REO properties under the National Stabilization Program’s “First Look Sales Method.” The NAID requirement for purchasers is...

Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and their federal regulator do not appear to have made much headway in convincing the mortgage industry to support a switch to a fee-for-service approach to servicing government-sponsored enterprise single-family mortgages. The vast majority of comments filed with the Federal Housing Finance Agency in response to its white paper on servicing compensation were from small and mid-sized lenders. The FHFA outlined two possible approaches, including its plan to pay servicers a flat fee of as little as $10 a month to service performing loans, with additional payments for...

There are new signs of life in the market for mortgage servicing rights, where observers suggest real estate investment trusts could become significant buyers and the government-sponsored enterprises are facilitating more transfer activity. Newcastle Investment Corp. recently announced a $44 million investment in excess mortgage servicing rights, done jointly with Nationstar Mortgage, a mortgage special servicer. Both companies are affiliates of Fortress Investment Group, a global investment management firm. Newcastle, a commercial mortgage real estate investment trust, acquired 65 percent...

For the past 18 years, listeners to the nationally-syndicated Dave Ramsey Show have heard the host recommend Nashville-based Churchill Mortgage. While Ramsey’s debt-free living message might seem at odds with a mortgage banking company issuing loans, Churchill Mortgage has found in Ramsey an excellent partner. “We get phone calls and hits to our website from every state in the country,” said Matt Clarke, Churchill’s CFO and COO. “The population of callers is largely high quality borrowers.” Churchill has been a sponsor of the Dave Ramsey show since it began, and continues to reap benefits. The question...

The one category of distressed loan that the federal government has the most control over – mortgages insured by the FHA and VA – continues to show the worst success rates for loan modifications. After 12 months of post-modification seasoning, over half (51 percent) of government-insured loans were 60 days or more past due, according to a report issued this week by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. That compared to an overall 60+ re-default rate of 39 percent. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgages, along with loans held in the servicer’s portfolio, showed the best...

Some mortgage servicers have done a better job than others in adjusting to a market environment of high default and foreclosure rates, according to a new Barclays Capital report, and the difference can have a significant impact on the value of non-agency mortgage securities they service. Servicing is not as easy as it used to be and has come much more under the spotlight, Barclays noted. Servicers have to work with distressed borrowers to determine whether loan modification, refinance or liquidation is the most appropriate response. Servicer performance can be shaped by the composition of...

The Federal Housing Finance Agency should refrain from implementing a proposal that would overhaul the mortgage servicing compensation system as it has failed to make a “compelling case” as to why it is necessary to change a system that has “worked well for decades,” according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.In a comment letter sent to the Finance Agency earlier this month, MBA President and CEO David Stevens said the FHFA’s proposed changes would dramatically alter residential servicing, origination and secondary market operations, not necessarily for the better.“The current servicer compensation model is still the best approach and making radical changes, like the proposed ‘fee-for-service,’ will have dramatic impacts not just on originators, servicers and investors but also on borrowers in both the costs they pay to get a mortgage and the support they receive from their servicers,” said Stevens.