More than a year after the Federal Housing Finance Agency first announced its proposal to sell investors Fannie Mae foreclosed properties in bulk for rentals and two months into its second sale with less than 800 properties moved, market watchers are expressing skepticism about whether the program will ever advance beyond the pilot stage. Earlier this month, the FHFA announced that New York-based Cogsville Group LLC was the winning bidder of 94 Fannie-owned properties. The firm paid $2.1 million for a share in a joint venture with the GSE resulting in a transactional value to Fannie of $11.8 million or 86.2 percent of the properties’ estimated value.

Fannie Mae’s and Freddie Mac’s home retention activity declined for the most part during the second quarter of 2012, according to a new analysis of Federal Housing Finance Agency data by Inside The GSEs. Total loss mitigation activity – total home retention efforts and foreclosure alternatives combined – declined 11.4 percent during the second quarter of the year to 190,315. Total loss mitigation for the first six months of the year fell 18.6 percent to 405,127 compared to the same six-month period in 2011.

There is vast room for improvement in how Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac manage their deficiency collections following foreclosure but it is the GSEs’ regulator that should provide more “guidance” about how to effectively pursue and collect from strategic defaulters, concluded the Federal Housing Finance Agency’s official watchdog this week.The FHFA Office of Inspector General’s latest audit found that in 2011, Fannie’s and Freddie’s vendors pursued 35,231 deficiency accounts, with a combined value of about $2.1 billion. Of this amount, vendors recouped some $4.7 million, a dismal recovery rate of 0.22 percent.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have released new guidelines designed to bring more of the two GSEs’ servicing requirements into alignment. The updated policies, both issued Oct. 3, focus on aligning contracts and the enforcement of remedies with seller/servicers in compliance with a Federal Housing Finance Agency directive. “The requirements announced in this bulletin build on the success [of previous announcements], and through our work with Fannie Mae, provide servicers with greater clarity, consistency and transparency across the enterprises on how servicer performance will be measured,” explained Freddie in its announcement.

A plethora of new servicing rules from federal and state regulators are set to increase costs for servicers – particularly mid-sized and small servicers that have not faced servicing changes required by disciplinary actions. The latest and perhaps most significant proposal for servicing rules came from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in August. “Change imposes significant pressure on servicer costs, resources, and capacity,” David Stevens, president and CEO of Mortgage Bankers Association said last week in a comment letter submitted to the CFPB. “The mortgage industry has been going through chronic, piecemeal regulatory changes for some time, with no end in sight. The costs are becoming prohibitive for many smaller, and even larger, companies.” He warned...

Numerous industry representatives are calling upon the CFPB to significantly scale back its ambitious mortgage servicing rulemaking proposal ¨C with at least one trade group urging the bureau to withdraw it entirely. The proposed rules amend Regulation Z (which implements the Truth in Lending Act) and Regulation X (which implements the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act). The CFPB¡¯s rules aim to bring greater transparency to the mortgage servicing market with: clear monthly mortgage statements, a warning before interest rate adjustments, options for avoiding costly...

Opponents of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act that created the CFPB are finding some initial success in chipping away at various provisions of the law through legal challenges. So far, authorities of the bureau itself have escaped the crosshairs of such legal challenges. However, the legitimacy of President Barack Obama’s appointment of Richard Cordray as director of the CFPB has been challenged in a round-about manner. So far, federal regulators have twice lost in court in their efforts to defend some of the rules they put in place...

A federal district court in Minnesota rejected a mortgage securitization trustee’s plea to compel a lender to repurchase defective home loans after finding that the loans no longer existed following the foreclosure and sale of the mortgaged properties. Ruling in MASTR Asset-Backed Securities Trust 2006-HE3 v. WMC Mortgage Corp., U.S. District Court Judge John Tunheim granted the lender’s motion for partial summary judgment after determining that the loans had been extinguished when the trustee foreclosed on the properties and charged off the remaining principal balances. The dispute boiled down...

With the planned acquisition of Homeward Residential, Ocwen Financial fired the latest shot as nonbank special servicers compete to grow their portfolios. While officials at Ocwen noted the “synergistic” benefits of the planned purchase, industry analysts warned that the move puts Ocwen in a shaky financial position. The company announced last week that it plans to acquire Homeward for $588 million in cash and $162 million in Ocwen stock. The acquisition will strengthen Ocwen’s position as the largest ...

“Servicers are less likely to act on the first-lien mortgage owned by investors when they themselves own the second-lien mortgage secured by the same property,” according to a new study based on data collected by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency from 10 large bank servicers. The study confirms suspicions that bank servicers are conflicted regarding loss mitigation, particularly because their second-lien holdings continue to perform relatively well even as corresponding first liens have ...