The battle over legacy MBS continues to rage in courts across the country as Bank of New York Mellon filed repurchase-related lawsuits against two financial institutions, Massachusetts Mutual was allowed to proceed with its claims against Countrywide, and a federal banking regulator sued major banks for alleged MBS misrepresentations. On Aug. 21, BNY Mellon, in its capacity as trustee for a pool of loans known as GE-WMC Mortgage Securities Trust 2006-1, sued WMC Mortgage and GE Mortgage Holdings for their alleged failure to repurchase approximately $680 million in defective residential mortgages. According to the lawsuit filed in New York state court, a holder of more than 25 percent of the voting rights under the pooling and servicing agreement notified...

The Federal Housing Finance Agency is pushing its own version of mortgage reform: an ambitious agenda of standardizing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac securitization operations to the point that their MBS are interchangeable. The plan, hatched in the absence of any substantial move by Congress or the Obama administration to address the nearly four-year-old conservatorships of the government-sponsored enterprises, has won broad endorsement from the lending and securitization industries. But some analysts say the FHFA strategy will make things worse, not better. Karen Shaw Petrou, managing partner of Federal Financial Analytics, a proprietary think-tank in Washington, DC, characterized the idea as “seductive” and “dangerous as all get-out.” First, there’s the issue of whether the two GSEs could be...

Following the collapse of the non-agency market, critics of banks have suggested that MBS issuers could be liable for significant tax payments due to violations of real estate mortgage investment conduit rules. However, the IRS has yet to act on the issue and officials at the IRS downplayed suggestions of a wide-scale investigation. REMICs receive tax advantages as passive, static investments. The IRS requires that mortgages be transferred to the trust within a certain timeframe, usually within 90 days after the trust is created. Some have suggested that the improper assignment of mortgages to REMICs is...

$7.5 Million FHA Mortgage Fraud Scheme. The Department of Justice has filed charges against top executives of a real estate brokerage for their participation in a mortgage fraud scheme that may cost the FHA $7.5 million in losses. Indictments were unsealed earlier this month in Manhattan federal court charging Mitchell Cohen and Erin Davis, the owner and sales manager, respectively, of Buy-A-Home, a real estate brokerage business in Queens, NY. The criminal charges follow a civil fraud lawsuit filed by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York last December against ...

A lawsuit filed last week by Bank of New York Mellon against WMC Mortgage and GE Mortgage Holdings is the latest sign that repurchase issues on non-agency mortgage-backed securities are increasing. After years of resistance, trustees are starting to act on behalf of non-agency MBS investors seeking repurchases. Three of the four major banks reported increases in non-agency repurchase requests in the second quarter of 2012 compared with the previous quarter, according to an analysis by Inside Nonconforming Markets ...

The rating services report increasing inquiries regarding potential ratings for securitization of income from real-estate owned rental properties. The first REO rental non-agency mortgage-backed security could be issued later this year, but Suzanne Mistretta, a senior director at Fitch Ratings, suggested that AAA ratings are unlikely initially. “The lack of historical data and ambitious growth strategies by regional operators will make high investment-grade ratings on these transactions difficult ...

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s newly amended preferred stock purchase agreement with the U.S. Treasury requiring the companies to accelerate the rate at which they reduce their investment portfolios will have little immediate impact but will become more challenging to the GSEs as time goes on, analysts predict. The Treasury’s amended agreement calls for the GSE portfolios to be wound down at an annual rate of 15 percent, instead of the 10 percent annual reduction originally required of the two companies. The more aggressive 15 percent reductions will go into effect in 2013. Consequently, Fannie’s and Freddie’s portfolios must be reduced to the $250 billion target by 2018, four years earlier than initially scheduled.

The Federal Housing Finance Agency became the biggest opponent of proposals for local governments to use eminent domain to seize underwater loans from non-agency mortgage-backed securities. “FHFA has determined that action may be necessary on its part to avoid a risk to safe and sound operations at its regulated entities and to avoid taxpayer expense,” the conservator of the government-sponsored enterprises said in response to the proposed use of eminent domain to forgive principal on mortgages ...

Bank and thrift holdings of residential MBS changed very little in the second quarter of 2012, although the portfolios of several of the biggest depository institution investors revealed substantial changes from the previous period. A new Inside MBS & ABS analysis of call report data showed a 1.5 percent decline in total residential MBS held by banks and thrifts during the second quarter. After hitting a record $1.634 trillion as of the end of March, banks and thrifts reported $1.610 trillion in MBS in their held-to-maturity and available-for-sale portfolios as of the end of June. Even with the decline since March, bank and thrift MBS holdings were...[Includes two data charts]

Standard & Poor’s announced late last week that it updated the criteria for ratings on non-agency MBS with mortgage collateral originated before 2009. The new standards are effective immediately and will result in significantly more downgrades than upgrades, according to S&P analysts. The standards update criteria for credit, cash flows and rating stability, and introduce new methods for analyzing transactions that have fewer than 100 loans remaining in the pool. Vandana Sharma, a managing director and lead analytic manager for U.S. residential MBS ratings at S&P, said the new standards reflect key market trends. “In light of the stabilization of home prices and delinquencies in the U.S. mortgage market, these criteria seek...