A scathing criticism of the way the Federal Housing Finance Agency and Freddie Mac handled a $1.35 billion settlement with Bank of America could cause the regulator and the government-sponsored enterprises to tighten repurchase enforcement – and consequently inflate the buyback problem, according to litigation experts. Speaking on a recent webinar hosted by Inside Mortgage Finance, experts said a report by the FHFA’s Office of the Inspector General which found flaws in the BofA settlement approval process, could push the GSEs and their regulator to lean harder on major lenders to repurchase “bad loans.” This, in turn, could...

The Securities and Exchange Commission has made a good bit of progress in updating its proposal for shelf eligibility conditions for ABS in light of industry comments and the passage of the Dodd-Frank Act. However, there are still numerous areas that concern major players in the mortgage finance industry. A number of commenters took issue with the SEC’s proposal to impose an additional executive officer certification requirement. The agency originally proposed requiring the issuer to file an exhibit to the registration statement consisting of a certification of the chief executive officer of the depositor that, to his or her knowledge, “the securitized assets backing the issue have...

The chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform wants the Federal Housing Finance Agency to explain why it hired two outside law firms in a massive legal action to recover losses suffered by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac on their investments in non-agency MBS. Rep. Darrell Issa, R-CA, wrote FHFA Acting Director Edward DeMarco on Sept. 29 asking why the agency hired outside counsel from Quinn Emanuel & Sullivan and from Kasowitz Benson Torres & Freidman to initiate lawsuits against financial institutions and how much the agency is paying them. Issa posed detailed questions and requested documents regarding...

Federal Housing Finance Agency. OIG Finds Room for Improvement. The FHFA recognizes how important it is to oversee Fannie Mae’s and Freddie Mac’s default-related legal services, but it needs to improve its capacity to identify new and emerging areas of risk, according to a new report released by the agency’s Office of Inspector General. Additionally, “FHFA does not have a continuous supervision plan or detailed examination guidance to govern its oversight of Fannie’s Retained Attorney Network, and it had not accomplished any targeted examinations of the RAN until it initiated a special review in late 2010, which has not yet been published,” the OIG said. Moreover, “FHFA also has not developed formal policies to address poor performance by law firms that have relationships – either directly through contract or through its loan servicers – with both enterprises to ensure that information is shared.”

The credit rating industry is generally making progress in implementing a landslide of new regulatory requirements – both in the U.S. and from overseas regulators – but several firms continue to wrestle with conflict-of-interest standards and other issues, according to an annual report released this week by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Problems were found at all 10 ratings firms. The three larger nationally recognized statistical rating organizations – Standard and Poor’s, Moody’s Investors Service and Fitch Ratings – all have more than 1,000 credit analysts and credit analyst supervisors, while...

Securitization market participants continue to face significant uncertainty from regulatory forces on both sides of the Atlantic that is dampening securitization activity, raising costs and probably leaving some deals undone. Much of the problem stems from capital requirements and the use of credit ratings, which have fallen into disrepute among many lawmakers and regulators in the wake of the collapse of the subprime mortgage market and the resulting credit market freeze in 2008. After last year’s enactment of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, the Federal Reserve, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., the...

Between 2006 and early 2011, Fannie Mae’s regulator repeatedly tolerated delays by the GSE in establishing an acceptable and effective operational risk-management program despite repeated calls to do so, according to a report by the Federal Housing Finance Agency Office of Inspector General.

A report issued this week by the Federal Housing Finance Agency Office of Inspector General found preventable flaws in the FHFA’s oversight and approval of a $1.35 billion settlement between Bank of America and Freddie Mac in December 2010 which resolved most past, present and future repurchase demands on 787,000 loans.Fannie Mae made its own similar repurchase settlement with BofA for $1.52 billion that same month.The FHFA-OIG evaluation found the agreement was based on Freddie’s flawed review process and that a “lack of independent action by FHFA senior management may have led and could lead to significant losses” by the GSE.

States are moving quickly to implement laws and regulations facilitating “eExamination” of mortgage lenders, leveraging technological innovation to bring the industry closer towards the goal of self-examination and self-regulation. “We are close to 30 states that are doing eExaminations, and we’re trying to bring on additional states as we move forward,” said Michael Chan, vice president of technology vendor Compliance Ease. “One of the reasons why I would say we’re reaching a tipping point is that state regulators are conducting limited-scope electronic exams,” he added. The idea behind that is...

The Securities and Exchange Commission is considering launching a civil injunctive action against Standard & Poor’s Rating Services, alleging violations of federal securities laws with respect to the company’s ratings for a 2007 collateralized debt obligation. According to a Form 8-K filing this week by McGraw-Hill, the rating service’s parent, the federal agency is looking into S&P’s rating of Delphinus CDO 2007-1, which was to be mostly backed by non-agency residential MBS. “In connection with the contemplated action, the [SEC] staff may recommend that the commission seek civil money penalties, disgorgement of fees and...